In this blog I share some of the ideas and thoughts that I have developed in the context of teaching skills and techniques in drawing, painting and related areas. The posts below are written in a style that aims to encourage discussions amongst people about practical aspects of working creatively rather than focus on academic debate. The emphasis in my posts is about establishing and sustaining a creative practice and considering how creative work might affect our sense of self and the challenges this might bring.
Wanting to make original artwork?
A person might say….: “ When making art, I’d like to come up with something ON MY OWN….”. “Something that has originality.”
What do we actually mean with our wish to come up with work ‘that is generated, ….own our own?
Here are two quick answers to the question – for now: firstly, we might mean that this ‘own thing’ has been generated without anybody else prompting us to do it. And, secondly, that for us, as the makers of this new thing, we recognise the uniqueness and novel character of it – we don’t need others to convince our humble creative self that we have done something special and new. Because we see it for ourselves that it is.
OK. So far so good.
I am now going to suggest some further considerations about these two answers, one at a time.
There is originality and there is novelty.
Some artwork or artmaking approach has a novelty character when it has not been done before, or done before like THAT. How much novel character something has can be difficult to ascertain because we’d have to make a search to compare our new thing to others’ work. And, we simply have to assume that there will always be somewhere somebody who has done something similar.
Does this novelty character still matter us so much? I suggest to leave this facet of originality for now and think about another dimension of it.
‘Originality’ in artmaking might already occur, when we make art based on being driven by our own authentic emotionality, using our feelings, our senses, our whole sensory system to engage with the artmaking process.
The outcome of this process will then be unique - due to these aspects. This uniqueness makes the work original.
However, we may not rate this very dimension of originality very highly – the uniqueness based on our personal subjectivity - maybe, because we may not have so much awareness or interest in the fact that artmaking is driven by our own subjective particularity. Or, it might be that even though we have an awareness of this uniqueness, we may not want to emphasise it particularly or give ourselves enough permission for this uniqueness to show in the work. But we could do.
It might also be that this uniqueness may not mean so much to us because we find it more exciting to pick up the ‘thrill of the other’ in other people’s creative output rather than accept that our own creative voice ‘sounds like THIS’.
Engaging with our own creative voice can sometimes be challenging because the uniqueness of our output not only reveals the sound or look of ‘me’, but it also may reveal where we have made mistakes, where we have not yet addressed improvements or learning that might need doing. Awareness of all these dimensions of our artmaking process requires a lot of acceptance. So, engaging with our own subjective, personal uniqueness and how it can come out in artmaking makes the work original.
But, as the makers of our own art, we might want ‘more’ from our artmaking process, beyond the authenticity that drives our process.
For this reason, I suggest we look at the wider aspects of uniqueness – at uniqueness from the context of our working process.
Our circumstances of artmaking are unique.
Our personal situation ,where we are in life, how we respond to its challenges and joys are unlike anybody else’s. How we live our lives, how our money-making requirements determines what happens with us, how our social situations impact on what we do next. All these aspects inform our artmaking. We also respond to limitations and possibilities and we make choices when it comes to artmaking materials and mediums. We also have preferences that others don’t have and we make our art in unique surroundings and circumstances.
Some people’s arts practices are determined by the fact that they can only ever work on a table that is tiny and store minimal amounts of things. There are wider aspects to our work that impact on how we choose to make our art: we may come from a family of farmers; our life could be determined by the family’s situation in an area of war and conflict; a personal experience of loss or an accident may be a factor that determines how we feel or are able to respond. These aspects of uniqueness, will always inform our artmaking. Nobody’s circumstantial situation is alike yours.
So we can consider uniqueness in somebody’s artmaking to reside not only in their embodied and emotional subjectivity but also in the particularity of their wider circumstantial situation.
However, whilst some artmakers are happy for their artmaking to be based exactly onto these aspects, and no more, some others may ‘ask more’ of their artmaking than ‘just’ be an expression of and response to subjective and circumstantial contexts.
For this reason, let us think about the results and the processes of our artmaking process.
In order to recognise that our artmaking has originality, we may want to get an intuitive confirmation, from within our own reflections about our creative work, that this originality happens. We want to ascertain this for ourselves, rather than be told by others.
Here is a string of argumentationsthat might convince you of it, though: instead of considering the values of one single artmaking outcome, e.g. a picture, or a song, I suggest to think about your whole artmaking process. A singular artmaking result is always embedded into a process of making.
Often, we may have artwork that we did in the past.
Then, there is artwork that we are working on at the moment.
And, we may plan for future work.
(One thing is clear, though – you have to start making things – before the whole debate about the value of your creative output can happen - demanding to know what artmaking might have originality, or rather not work at all would be the mindset of illusionist.)
The artmaking process
Artmaking is a process that is not focussed alone on the production of one single item. There is always the next one. The next piece of art happens because we respond and deal with the work we did earlier; because we draw conclusions, realise what went well and what did not.
We establish and deal with our earlier mode of art production, and we plan for the future one. Considerations to ponder are what we want to try out next, what we need to improve, what materials we want to work with. And then, in the context of all this, we might have to learn how to be kinder to ourselves and not demand the impossible, and at other times, we have to be harder to push through a barrier.
Artmaking is not for the faint-hearted. It involves the whole self. It humbles us. Accepting that we never stop to learn is important. Some people discover that artmaking can jeopardise their sense of self because it reveals so much about our fragilities.
Artmaking is a process that involves making decisions and forming opinions. About what we have done before, what happens now, what we might do next. Purposeful intentionality is part of this.
The uniqueness of our artmaking process comprises our goals, our preferences, what we have learnt of working with THESE materials, and with ourselves.
In summary – you already got all that is required to make unique work. You just need to do it: you have got unique circumstances for working and for referencing themes that connect to you and your life. And, your drawing and painting style is unique anyway due to you being you.
So, get started and do your work.
I want to make some suggestions about getting started….
1. Find what practical artwork you
……can already do,
……have lots of fun doing it, and,
….. can do on your own (without the help of a teacher, advisor, or peer group), and,
……can do it ‘at home’.
This activity should be something you have clarity about – about what you do, how you do it, what you need to get started. It needs to be something that you have done before. This activity must not be a challenge for you. It needs to feel quite all right to do.
2. Do it: at home and on your own and apply its visual themes to your particular life, person, circumstances and environment.
3. Do it again, and again. You don’t need to think much about new themes, or new materials. Just go along what the process suggests to you. Repeat. Don’t fall into the trap of quickly stretching your ideas for further development to variations of your artmaking that require a lot of expensive materials or lots of time. You need to focus on the doing rather than having to solve logistical problems.
4. Repeat what you do. The repetition of your process will invite and suggest variations for you. Do the repetitions. Then the variations.
Group your work into series: Sets of 3 or 4 or five works.
Compare the series with each other.
5. Reflect about your work – this is an essential part of your new practice. You could write down your thinking.
How does your current work compare to some work you did earlier. What is new? What has changed?
What did you enjoy doing? (Why?)
What was hard to do? (Why?)
Have you learnt new skills? (Which ones?)
What would you like to do next?
What are your hopes for further work in the future?
6. Invite a nice person and show this person what you have done. Talk them through your work. Then, do some more work. And repeat.
For being able to produce your own unique art and develop your own unique arts practice, you do not need to first work up towards a certain skills level with particular techniques until ‘you are ready’. In fact, it is best to base your artmaking not on some skills that you might develop in the future. You should build it from the regularity and discipline of showing up to do work, from your motivation to move forward, the joy and fun that making gives you. Choose something you can already do, and make it your own.
Mindsets – your own….and, other people’s
When you start working creatively, you may find, that gradually, your mind-set changes: you may discover that you change the expectations you have for your creative outcomes, the speed of your learning, and why you are doing your creative work.
You may also find that you begin to value what you do differently, and that you develop a sense of continuity between your earlier creative results, what you do now, and what you intend to do in the future. How you value what you do right now and how you think about your creative future is changing.
Such thoughts might come along with further reflections about yourself: doing creative work often questions the way we know ourselves and this is embedded in the wider contexts of scribing our own identity.
Creative work changes you.
The creative work that you do may also change your beliefs about such themes as ‘talent’, or ‘creativity’, how creative work happens, and your legitimacy to engage in creative pursuits.
It may happen that whilst you are shifting your approaches and ideas about creative activities, the people around you still hold the same views about creativity and associated themes as they always have – and about you in connection to these themes.
You may now discover that their opinions about you and their comments about your artmaking can make you doubtful of your own new - but still fragile - creative growth.
With or without the challenge of other people’s opinions, it may still happen, that though you are moving forward nicely with your creative pursuits, you still have doubtful moments when you ‘flop’ back into an older version of your self in which you were extremely critical of your creative outcomes. Or, you may have negative internal chatter that makes you feel very insecure about your current artmaking.
Keep going with your art.
The internal chatter will become more quiet. Though, …. ,some of it might never go away… Such is life in art.
Even if you are faced with other people’s unhelpful comments – and in all likeliness they do not mean to cause any harm …. keep going. Instead, and, in addition, you may have to grow some resilience …
There are a lot of misunderstandings around about the nature of ‘talent’, who should and should not do art, what a good drawing looks like, and how long it takes to develop the skill to produce correct proportions. Even though I have been working in art and design for over 40 years, and hold a PhD from research into creative practice, I regularly come across people whose frameworks for thinking about artmaking cannot be changed in spite of my best efforts.
De-personalise the challenge!
We all have internal chatter: inside our head, a voice, our own voice, talks to us. This communication we have with ourselves is often about things that trouble us, that we can’t get a handle on. How things work for us with our creative development can be a troublesome theme of our internal chatter.
Establishing and maintaining a creative practice often means that our wishes about how we would like to work, what we would like to achieve and how we hope that artmaking ‘feels like’ is very different from how it actually happens.
Nothing is easy. Creative work means that we constantly have to solve problems, and we deal with ‘not knowing’ about things: not knowing what to do next, how to overcome a lack of skills (yes, we are working on developing them…) or why something has not worked. Some artist colleagues of mine are able to assess such situations and analyse and evaluate them. They might trace the problem to the inappropriateness of their artmaking tools, and they might also devise a plan to acquire required skills, or improve the working environment. I am not one of these people for whom such analysis and evaluation comes easily. Though I know that improvement sits in the betterment of the factors mentioned above - I get a lot of distraction in my head that relates my not-so-successful artmaking to my person: I tell myself, that I am guilty of not working efficiently enough, that I SHOULD have conquered this artmaking challenge a long time ago, but, because I am lazy I have not. I might even feel that the situation at hand is just the perfect manifestation of how little talent I have got for doing this kind of creative activity (oh… the topic of talent….). Should I - at all - be doing this? I might be wasting my time ….
Negative self-chatter, guilt, and blaming yourself, … we have learnt to resort to these strategies because the emotional pain that comes with them is so hard to bear that we just might try harder. Such strategies are often the result of others wanting us to do things. I recommend not to rely on growing and sustaining an arts practice on negativity about yourself. But, you might say…. “…at least, be… ‘r e a l i s t i c’…you are NOT a great painter…..”! As a justification for our negativity, we believe that we cannot do without realism in a situation of doubt. Negative down-talk diminishes your ability to engage with and feel the colours, the flow of your linework on the paper, to imagine new artwork and respond to what inspires you. When you get negative internal chatter about the value of your person, or your work, or your talent - give yourself the permission, to admit to yourself that it happens. Denial won’t work. Then, try to disengage from it. The artmaking process has plenty of more useful aspects that you need to concentrate on. De-personalise your challenge: try to trace what is not working to your tools use and techniques, and to your artmaking intentions. And, modify your expectations. What are the exact reasons why this picture has not worked? Find out exactly the FACTS of your challenging situation. If you can’t find a solution - try again, and again. Speak to others - they may have encountered the same problem. But: de-personalise the challenge. Make yourself free from guilt, blame, negative attributes - they will only twist what is the real challenge at hand: the materials you work with, the skills you got or not got, the patterns of artmaking you employ. You need your personal sensing capacities for seeing and feeling colour, for touching paper with a brush or performing the next movement of your arm to produce a brushstroke on paper. Have trust in the practical making of things. It will get better.
It is true, however, that dealing with negative internal chatter is not something you can just switch off that easily. Some of us may have patterns of feeling guilt, blame, or embarrassment that get triggered when particular things happen to us - artmaking situations might start the pattern for us. For many creative people, artmaking may mean to be dealing with two challenges: firstly, with the artmaking process, and, secondly, with our own self-awareness in the context of a creative undertaking. I have a lot of personal experience with these challenges…. with trying to play music…and the negative self-chatter got in the way. I can report however, that I stubbornly stuck with the pursuit of it…and, I have managed to play and convince myself out of my difficulties. Currently, I am learning to windsurf - and, I am dealing with both, the self-chatter and the learning of skills. Yes, I am making progress….and so can you!
Get your markers in!
Sometimes, we only got a few minutes to work on something. We may not even be in our usual place where we have all our materials and the familiarity of surroundings. In fact, the particularity about this arising possibility to paint, or draw or make some notes feels awkward… it may not fit our criteria and expectations for what needs to be right for you to start working. You might think that something is ‘too difficult’ about the situation, e g. you have landed in an artmaking group where you believe that everybody is on a higher level (what is a higher level….?). You might feel insecure about starting because you have questions about what you will get out of if, if it is worth digging into this opportunity, or, if you might risk to increase your insecurities. I suggest you take the opportunity and get your markers in - even if you find that the situation is not perfect according to your usual intentions. Establishing or maintaining a regular arts practice is full of challenges. And, it is harder to get yourself used to working regularly when you have not yet developed this pattern of working. Every occasion that you grab to engage with the divers insecurities that artmaking presents is like a walk undertaken in an unfamiliar landscape. Even if you don’t manage to see all the sights and manoeuvre all the challenges on the ground, you will still reduce your unfamiliarity with the artmaking landscape, and replace areas labelled as “I don’t know” with “have some experience”. This will massively increase your believe in yourself. We gain confidence by having consciously navigated difficulties. So, put your markers in!!
Making it easy for yourself
It can be hard work to establish a pattern of regularly working on your own creative project. Daily lives are huge distractions and starting out to establish a rhythm of working again and again on your creative interests is difficult not only because of the organisation, motivation, commitment and practical arrangements this necessitates but also because you need to push other positions in your daily or weekly schedules aside to make space. I find that it is harder to establish a new habit of working on something than it is to maintain a practice that I have already established. I compare my artmaking a lot with other activities in my life that I like to do, e.g. playing guitar or going out for a bike ride. On a Saturday morning I go on a bike ride. On Tuesday night, I join my band mates for music rehearsals. In the absence of external circumstances, e.g. dates to work with other people or joining a class where you have committed to book your place, there is less requirement to adhere to your plan to show up and work. When working on your own, setting your on schedule for when such work happens and where is difficult. Yet, this kind of independent work that you might do all on your own follows your own interests, develops your personal, unique artmaking skills and builds your confidence. I suggest that you consider the following idea when you are starting out to develop your own arts practice: make it easy for yourself! Choose to do practical work that is not too difficult, that you might already know how to do, and of which you know that you like doing it. Don’t aim high with expectations for outcomes (we are our best enemies when it comes to aiming too high, for goals that are - realistically seen - too far way), but aim for a regular return to your desk. If you want - as a goal for your whole practice - to engage with the landscape of a certain valley - don’t demand of yourself to paint a full on picture in your first sitting. You might just start to sort out your paints, and make tests of the paints you got, spots of paint on paper…. Don’t aim and plan for three hour sessions - they may require a huge reshuffling of other daily schedules - start with 10 minutes of sitting down. Making it easy for yourself and lowering expectations will take the pressure out of your next practical session. Aiming for a short amount of time to be spent working - and then maybe staying longer, because it was easy to do - works well to establish a temporal pattern of working creatively. What matters most at this stage is that you return to your desk. Admittedly, it can be challenging to know what alternatives to your big goals you might have to establish your practice. The less familiar you are with the practical whereabouts of your creative interest, the more difficult it might be to understand what alternatives you might have to work, the alternatives to the big-goal-approach. It is always helpful to seek out communication with other people, talk to them about your work, and the problems you encounter; other artists have exactly these kind of issues too!
Creative work changes you as a person
We all have a certain concept of ourselves. Who we are, what we do, how we relate our own story about ourselves and our world. When we start doing creative work, we may find out that we have to change our assumptions about ourselves and our stories. Working creatively is a forward progression marked by trial and error. Not all our attempts will work as we expected. We might call such outcomes ‘a mistake’ or, better, an ‘unexpected results’. The mistakes that we make when we work creatively may challenge our concept of ourselves. Many of us have tried all our lives to avoid mistakes as we aim for being as successful as we can. Creative work is different. We only improve when we try things out and we have to accept that part of progression is to discover what does not work. We might find that it is hard for us to accept this. It may also be that we struggle to negotiate with ourselves that we actually DO manage to do creative things. How does this sit with the concept of the self that we might have had so far? Often, part of the stories that we tell ourselves about ourselves is that we are NOT creative… but now, we actually find out that, we are?
Also, we might find it difficult to make other people in our lives understand that we are doing creative work. We might feel hesitation to engage in creative things because we just don’t know how to explain and justify this ‘new thing’ to others. Sharing stories about your practical creative work and how you feel about making it is the best way to deal with such issues!